2008 - Cashes Mason, second team
2007 - Nick Gullickson, second team
2006 - Jason Steege and Nate Schmidt, first team; Rance Cartmill, second team
2005 - Nate Schmidt, MVP; Dick Peth, Coach of Year; Jason Steege, first team; Jordan Atchison, second team
2004 - Jason Steege, first team
2003 - Mike Pipho, first team; Jake Olsen and Dan Schuknecht, second team
2002 - Mike Pipho, first team; Jake Olsen, second team
2001 - Troy Osterhaus, Most Valuable Player; Dick Peth, Coach of Year; Patrick Morrison, first team; Mike Pipho, second team; Marcus Meeks, second team
2000 - Troy Osterhaus, first team; Patrick Morrison, second team
1999 - Trent Hoover, first team; Thad Peck, second team
1998 - Rich Kloster, first team; Thad Peck, second team
1997 - Rich Kloster, second team
1996 - Eric Foote, second team
1995 - Matt Freeseman, second team
1994 - Rob Kain, second team
1993 - Matt Leary, first team; Brian Farrell, second team
1992 - Lance Haupt, first team
1991 - Mark Olenius and Todd Reinhardt, first team
1990 - Todd Reinhardt, first team; Dan Nettleton, second team
1989 - Mike Murphy, Most Valuable Player; Buzz Levick, Coach of Year; Rich Williamson, second team
1988 - Mike Murphy, first team
1987 - Mike Murphy, first team; Buzz Levick, Coach of Year; Barry Huber, second team
1986 - Ward Prine, first team
1985 - Ward Prine, second team
1984 - Rich Barnett, first team
1983 - Mark Merritt and Greg Schmitz, first team
1982 - John Dickkut and Mark Merritt, first team; Greg Schmitz, second team
1981 - Matt Ellis, first team; Tony Burbach, second team
1980 - Matt Ellis, first team; Mike Barkley, second team
1979 - Mike Ellis, second team
1978 - Mark Fry, first team; Kirk Kinnear, second team
1977 - Mark Fry, first team; Jeff Werling, second team
1976 - Bud Johnson, first team; Rich Nickels, second team
1975 - Bud Johnson, Most Valuable Player; Buzz Levick, Co-Coach of Year; Ray Lantz, second team
1974 - Fred Waldstein and Steve Kohn, first team; J.D. Gardner, second team
1973 - Frank Stewart and Pete Griffin, first team; Buzz Levick, Coach of Year; J.D. Gardner, second team
1972 - Dave Platte. Most Valuable Player; Buzz Levick, Coach of Year; Frank Stewart, second team
1971 - Tom Manchester, first team; Dave Platte and Fred Grawe, second team
1970 - G.E. Buenning, Most Valuable Player; Buzz Levick, Co-Coach of Year; Tom Manchester, first team
1969 - G.E. Buenning and Cliff Cornelius, first team; Tom Manchester, second team
1968 - John Hearn, first team; G.E. Buenning, second team
1967 - John Hearn, first team; Dennis Bowman, second team
1966 - John Hearn, second team
1965 - Cliff Cameron, first team
1964 - Al Buenning, first team; Dick Ridout, second team
1963 - Dick Ridout, second team
1961 - Don Hein and Dave Jensen, first team
1960 - John Tuecke, first team; Don Hein, second team
1959 - John Tuecke and Dave Jensen, first team
1958 - John Adix, first team
1957 - Art Margheim, first team