Troy Osterhaus, Lutheran Brotherhood, second team/DIII News fifth team, 2001
Dan Nettleton (Academic) 1991
Dan Nettleton (Academic) 1990
Matt Ellis 1981
Fred Waldstein (Academic) 1974
Fred Waldstein (Academic) 1973
Tim Koch (Academic) 1972
Dave Platte (Academic) 1972
Dave Platte (Academic) 1971
G.E. Buenning 1970
G.E. Buenning 1969
John Adix 1958