1949 - Waldo Platte, End; Paul Bruns, Halfback
1953 - Wendell Liemohn, End; Charles Schumann, Tackle; Bob Kiester, Center; Ted Fritschel, Back
1954 - Wendell Liemohn, End; Charles Schumann, Tackle; Charles Bose, Back
1955 - Wendell Liemohn, End; Art Margheim, Quarterback
1957 - Arnie Brandt, Guard
1958 - Darwin Fritz, End; Marv Ott, Quarterback; Larry Raper, Fullback
1959 - Ron Krueger, Tackle; Larry Collmann, Center; Larry Raper, Fullback
1960 - Charles Wallin, Offensive Tackle; Marv Ott, Offensive Back; Don Sowers, Linebacker; Tom Van Wyngarden, Defensive Back; Wayne Dreier, Fullback; Larry Collmann, Linebacker
1961 - Don Sowers, Linebacker
1962 - Bob Wachholz, Offensive End; Paul Zietlow, Defensive Back
1963 - Dale Fridley, Offensive Tackle; Dave Van Ahn, Offensive Line; Eldon Ott, Defensive Back
1964 - Paul Zietlow, Offensive End; Ron Mennen, Linebacker
1965 - Roger Kittleson, Quarterback; Ron Mennen, Linebacker; Doug Sires, Defensive Back
1966 - Lyle Wind, Defensive Line
1967 - Al Anderson, Offensive Line; Murray McMurray, Linebacker
1968 - Paul Danielson, Running Back; Jerry Fox, Defensive Back; Terry Goetzinger, Tight End; Connie Hellerich, Linebacker; Bob Larson, Defensive Back; Murray McMurray, Offensive Guard; Gary Nelson, Running Back; Bob Olson, Tackle; Paul Specht, Quarterback
1969 - Paul Flynn, Offensive Line; Connie Hellerich, Defensive Back
1970 - Dale Bush, Offensive Line; Paul Flynn, Offensive Line; Jim Hotz, Offensive Line; Rod Miller, Defensive Line; Gary Nelson, Back; Dave Snell, Defensive Back
1971 - Rex Adams, Offensive Line; Dale Bush, Offensive Line; Joe Crawford, Defensive Line; Steve Roseland, Defensive Line; Tom Zackery, Offensive Line; Gary Zalaznik, Back
1972 - Joe Crawford, Defensive Line
1973 - Dave Berndt, Defensive Line; Doug Fencl, Defensive Back; Conrad Mandsager, Linebacker; Larry Nelson, Offensive Line
1974 - Al Bergman, Defensive Line; Dave Berndt, Defensive Line; Doug Fencl, Defensive Back; Roman Lubinecky, Offensive Line
1975 - Brian Albert, Linebacker; Dave Foltz, End; Mike Luber, Offensive Line; Chuck Peterson, Defensive Back; Dan Swift, Defensive Line
1976 - Brian Albert, Linebacker; Carl Cheeseman, Defensive End; Randy Groth, Defensive Back; Dan Swift, Defensive Line; Tom Whalen, Offensive Line
1977 - Mike Broghammer, Running Back; Carl Cheeseman, Kicker; Bob Dack, Offensive Line; Neil Mandsager, Linebacker; Bob Reiter, Defensive Tackle; Doug Sadler, Defensive Back; Mike Sojka, Defensive Tackle; Tom Whalen, Offensive Line
1978 - Tom Lause, Running Back; Kevin Murray, Offensive Line; Bob Saathoff, Defensive End; Mike Sojka, Defensive Tackle
1979 - Tom Cahalan, Defensive Back; Mike Lynn, Offensive Line; Bob Reiter, Defensive Line; Dave Waskow, Running Back
1980 - Randy Stanek, Defensive Back
1982 - Brad Bowman, Defensive Back; John Crosser, Defensive End; Scott Fritz, Tight End; Jeff Glaw, Defensive Line; Owen McClure, Defensive Back; Steve Rodriguez, Linebacker; Scot Simpson, Offensive Line; Brad Smoldt, Offensive Line; Gary Walljasper, Quarterback; Tim Walljasper, Offensive Line; Mike Ward, Running Back
1983 - Brad Bowman, Defensive Back; Carter Crews, Defensive End; Scott Fritz, Tight End; Jeff Glaw, Defensive Line; Dave Koll, Wide Receiver; Carl Montgomery, Running Back; Steve Rodriguez, Linebacker; Eric Schwarz, Defensive Back; Gary Walljasper, Quarterback; Tim Walljasper, Offensive Line
1984 - Darrin Ausman, Offensive Line; Brad Bowman, Defensive Back; Roger Britson, Linebacker; Chris Cartee, Tight End; Dave Koll, Wide Receiver; Steve Rodriguez, Linebacker; Jay Topp, Kicker; Gary Walljasper, Quarterback
1985- Darren Ausman, Offensive Line; Roger Britson, Offensive Line; Chris Cartee, Tight End; Dave Koll, Wide Receiver; Brad Ott, Running Back; Eric Schwarz, Defensive Back; Mike Suckow, Defensive End; Scott Wilson, Defensive Line
1986 - Roger Britson, Offensive Line; Chris Cartee, Tight End; Chad Hake, Defensive Back; Brad Ott, Running Back; Scott Wilson, Defensive Line
1987 - Kurt Boerm, Defensive Back; Chad Hake, Linebacker; Brad Ott, Running Back; Walt Vering, Offensive Line
1988 - Chad Hake, Linebacker; Andy Heying, Offensive Line
1989 - Darren Bohlen, Running Back; Brian Hart, Offensive Line; Kyle Kreinbring, Defensive Back; Kurt Luhring, Defensive Back
1990 - Craig Bode, Defensive End; Darren Bohlen, Running Back; Kyle Kreinbring, Defensive Back; Jeff Lindauer, Offensive Line; Kevin Skartvedt, Offensive Line; Pat Weber, Defensive Line; Jerry Wessels, Linebacker
1991 - Jason Boaz, Offensive Line; Craig Bode, Defensive Line; Mike Gabrielson, Wide Receiver; Andy Ott, Quarterback; Kevin Skartvedt, Offensive Line; Tony Van Oort, Defensive Back
1992 - Mark Kelly, Running Back; Koby Kreinbring, Linebacker; Tony Van Oort Defensive Back; Jim White, Offensive Line
1993 - Bobby Beatty, Running Back; Todd Casey, Tight End; Mike Elijah, Quarterback; Jeff Huegel, Offensive Line; Chad Klunder, Defensive Back; Koby Kreinbring, Linebacker; Jamey Parker, Offensive Line; Vince Penningroth, Defensive Line; Joe Walczyk, Linebacker
1994 - Grant Bearbower, Defensive End; Bobby Beatty, Running Back; Todd Casey, Tight End; Mike Elijah, Quarterback; Chad Klunder, Defensive Back; Jamey Parker, Offensive Line; Vince Penningroth, Defensive Line; Kyle Shaffer, Offensive Line; Don Smith, Wide Receiver; Bruce Wall, Wide Receiver
1995- Grant Bearbower, Defensive End-Linebacker; Steve Carr, Tight End; Marty Fredericks, Offensive Line; Derek Hartl, Wide Receiver; Stacy Mostrom, Defensive Line; Brian Nelson, Quarterback; Vince Penningroth, Defensive Line; James Rochford, Defensive Back; Brent Schmadeke, Defensive Back
1996 - Mark Hargrafen, Defensive Line; Andy Lockie, Defensive Back; Brian Nelson, Quarterback; Chris Reade, Offensive Line; James Rochford, Defensive Back; Trevor Shannon, Running Back; Anthony Souhrada, Defensive Line
1997 - Taylor Anderson, Linebacker; James Rochford, Defensive Back; Ryan Schutty, Defensive Line; Mitch Vap, Offensive Line
1998 - Taylor Anderson, Linebacker; David Devine, Defensive Back; Mark Hargrafen, Offensive Line; Scott Milburn, Defensive Back; Ryan Rausch, Wide Receiver; Ryan Schutty, Defensive Line; Trevor Shannon, Running Back; Anthony Souhrada, Defensive Line; Matt Wheeler, Quarterback
1999- Matt Wheeler, Quarterback; Joel Rochford, Offensive Line; Justin Galbraith, Offensive Line; Ryan Rausch, Wide Receiver; Dave Devine, Defensive Secondary; Tim Flynn, Wide Receiver; Anthony Souhrada, Defensive Line
2000 - Ryan Rausch, Wide Receiver; Joel Demro, Offensive Line; Justin Schmidt, Defensive End; Dave Devine, Defensive Back; Randy Laing, Linebacker; Bo Harris, Defensive Back; Tyler Molstre, Running Back; Scott Denner, Tight End; Justin Galbraith, Offensive Line
2001 - Joel Demro, Offensive Line; Justin Beatty, Running Back; Randy Laing, Defensive Back; Scott Denner, Tight End; Vince King, Defensive Line; Chad Winters, Defensive Line; Ryan Winters, Linebacker; Dan Achenbach, Wide Receiver; Jeff Voreis, Offensive Line; Jake Olsen, Quarterback; Cody Kelley, Defensive Back
2002 - Brad Hodapp, running back (1st team)/special teams (2nd team);Jeff Voreis, offensive lineman; Andy Heitman, offensive lineman; Jordan Maus, place-kicker; Ryan Winters, linebacker; Cody Kelley, defensive back; Brian McIntire, defensive back; J.J. Zearley, defensive end; Vince King, defensive back; Justin Bishop, linebacker; Jake Olsen, quarterback; Justin Beatty, running back
2003 - Brad Hodapp, running back (1st team); Jeff Voreis, offensive line (1st team); Andy Heitman, offensive line (1st team); Chris Winter, wide receiver (1st team); Reggie Doby, special teams (1st team); Cody Kelley, defensive back (1st team); Brian McIntire, defensive back (1st team); Vince King, defensive line (1st team); Matt Stoffel, linebacker (1st team); Justin Bishop, linebacker (1st team); Reed Hoskins, quarterback (2nd team); Mark Giesmann, punter (2nd team)
2004 - Andy Heitman, offensive line (1st team); Brian McIntire, defensive back (1st team); Noah Junge, defensive line (1st team); Chris Winter, wide receiver (2nd team); Dan Hammes, running back (2nd team); Tom Power, offensive line (second team); Alex Pollock, linebacker (2nd team)
2005 - Jason Ingle, offensive line (1st team); Alex Pollock, linebacker (1st team); Tom Power, offensive line (first team); Noah Junge, defensive line (1st team); Dan Hammes, running back (2nd team); Ben Thomsen, fullback (2nd team); Nick Weber, defensive back (2nd team)
2006 - Dan Hammes, running back (1st team); Lincoln Taylor, offensive line (1st team); Ben Hogan, offensive line (1st team); Nick Weber, defensive back (1st team); Spencer Herzberg, place-kicker (2nd team); Jason Lansing, defensive back (2nd team); Eric Bruhn, defensive line (2nd team); Ryan Gerardy, linebacker (2nd team); Kyle Goodchild, linebacker (2nd team)
2007 - Ben Hogan, offensive line (1st team); Nick Weber, defensive back (1st team); Eric Bruhn, defensive line (1st team); Kyle Goodchild (1st team); Nico Botembe, defensive line (1st team); Josh Van Rees, running back (2nd team); Ryan Hoerner, tight end (2nd team); Neil Suckow, running back/wide receiver (2nd team); Eric Lauterbach, linebacker (2nd team); Jason Lansing, defensive back (2nd team); Josh Faaborg, defensive back (2nd team); Stevan Kingery, punter (2nd team); Nick Weber, punt returner (2nd team)